to the side until I could get Dad’s attention, and then I jerked my head to the right, toward his office, and headed that way.
Carol was in there doing some paperwork. “Hey, Paul!”
“Hi.”
“How are you?”
Does anyone ever really want to know the answer to that question? “I’m just waiting for my dad to come in. I have to talk to him about something.”
“Oh. Do you need me to leave?”
I’ve always liked Carol. For an old person, maybe even older than Dad, she always seemed pretty with it. But how could I answer that? I was looking at her, feeling helpless, when Dad came in. He took one look at me and asked Carol if we could have a moment. It was an eternity before she shut the door from the other side.
“Paul?”
“It’s Chris.” I didn’t need to say anything else.
He walked slowly around his desk, limping heavily, touching everything solid he could reach, everything that wouldn’t move if he leaned on it, and sat in his chair. That calm I’d had was disappearing like so much fake fog in a horror flick. A few tears came out of nowhere and ran down my face.
“Where’s your mother?”
“Outside in the car. She didn’t want to stay at home alone, and she didn’t want to come in.” I swiped at my traitor eyes.
“Who drove?”
Who cares? “I did.”
He took a few deep breaths, rubbed his face, and then asked me how we’d found out. And I started bawling for real. It was almost like now that he knew, the burden was shifting onto him. When it had been just Mom and me, I’d had to be strong. I’m not sure whether I couldn’t carry the weight anymore or whether Dad had done something to take it off me and now I could let go. I’ve wondered about that a lot.
So I told him how Chris had rescued those other guys, how he was a hero. To keep myself from losing it too badly, I pictured Dean Pendleton’s blue wool hat, thinking that at last Chris had made up for letting him down. I told Dad everything Chris would want him to know.
What I wanted to tell him was that this was his fault, that Chris was dead because of him. I wanted to tell him that Chris had known he’d die, that he’d been really scared before he went back. I wanted to tell him why Chris felt he had nothing to keep him alive anymore, tell him about Mason. Maybe that’s why I was crying—because of what I couldn’t say.
I don’t think any of us slept all night. The room next to me, Chris’s room, seemed more than empty. More than hollow. I should have been used to not having anyone in it. It had been like that since Chris had signed up, but suddenly it was different. It was a black hole, and it was sucking all the light inside and devouring it.
In the morning I heard Mom get up, and I expected to hear Dad as well, since he’d been going to church with her for weeks. But it was only her.
I went downstairs and found her standing at the counter, watching the toaster. It was a cloudy day, and the light over the stove was on. I’ve always loved that light. Whenever the kitchen is dark and that light’s on, it seems like all the world is somewhere else, doing whatever it has to do, and the light over the stove creates this haven, this zone of peace and security, just for me. That morning, seeing the light from across the room, shining down on nothing and Mom off to the side in the darkness, it didn’t give me that feeling. Maybe it will again some day, when I can believe in peace again, when I can believe there are havens anywhere. That morning, seeing Mom’s tired face with the skin sagging in odd places, it felt to me like that light was—I dunno, inadequate. Pathetic.
She lifted her head slowly when she knew I was there. Then she looked back at the toaster.
“You going to church?” I asked. She nodded. “Dad isn’t up yet, you know.”
“He’s not going.”
We stood there like that, her watching the toaster, me watching her. I jumped a foot when the toast popped, when that jarring metallic crunching slapping noise shot out into the room. I said, “I’ll go with you.”
She didn’t say anything, didn’t even nod. She started buttering her toast. I headed back upstairs to wash my face and put on some clothes that would do for church, and when I got back to the kitchen Mom had made me some toast with butter and jam. She had made coffee for two, out of habit maybe, and I poured some. I’d never had it before, and it tasted terrible. Mom smiled at the face I made, so at least that was good.
“You might like that better with cream and sugar,” she suggested. She was right, but I still didn’t think it would ever be my favorite drink. Even so, I decided that I would start drinking it. I would just start, that’s all.
I drove. Chris used to drive her to church, and then Dad, and probably she liked that. We didn’t speak all the way. It felt surreal to me. Like we’d crossed into another world somehow, just driving along, not many cars on the road, gray light and dead-looking trees all around us.
We sat in the same pew as my uncle Jeff, mom’s brother, and his wife, Diane. Mom had called them last night, sobbing more than talking, and Aunt Diane had come over and they’d cried together. They nodded to me and smiled sadly, and Aunt Diane reached over and squeezed my arm. Probably Mom and Chris had always sat with them when he drove her. My aunt had had two miscarriages years ago and then I guess they’d decided against trying for any more, so at least there were no irritating cousins I’d have to deal with.
I’d forgotten about organ music. Don’t know how I could have, it’s so much a part of the experience. When I used to come here as a kid, the only parts I liked were singing the hymns and listening to the organ. Though it always made me a little crazy when the organist would try to do improv stuff on the last verse. I wanted the music to be familiar all the way through, damn it, and it was like they ruined the end for me.
Didn’t take long for me to figure out that they were still up to their old tricks. Still ruining the end. In one way, I didn’t mind; I mean, I hadn’t been here in so long I couldn’t exactly have anything to say about how things were done. On the other, I felt a real need for something—anything—to feel familiar. To feel like there was something that didn’t get yanked out from under you. But the service felt familiar, anyway. Different minister from the one I remembered; had Mom mentioned that at some point? She must have. This guy seemed a little younger. And maybe a little more with it, but it was still a sermon.
It was Christmas season, so the readings were full of things anticipated, a coming birth, the dawning of a new hope. Yeah, right. I glanced at Mom to see how she was taking this. She was looking at me, her eyes moist, but she didn’t look sad, exactly. She looked—wistful, maybe? Hopeful? What do I have to do with hope? I didn’t feel like smiling, but I did anyway, just to give her a little encouragement; at least she wasn’t sobbing, which I’d half thought she might do. I mean, there’s nothing like everyone else sounding cheerful when you’ve been hit by a bus to make you feel even more like shit.
Several times as I sat there, I felt sure I was supposed to be praying or something. Was there really no place in the service where everyone just sat still and had a word with Jesus? But then I thought, what would I say? Besides, God had probably forgotten about me. So mostly I just sat there and let things wash over me.
During the last part of the service Mom took my hand. I couldn’t quite remember the last time she did that. She held it until the final hymn was announced and we had to fumble in the hymnals, and I was thinking that maybe she and Chris used to do that. Hold hands.
So I’m hope now? I’m the hand-holder? One voice in my head said, “Oh, I don’t think so.” Another said, “Why not?” It was like that old comic book image where a devil was on one shoulder, and an angel on the other. “No way.” “Why not?” “You can’t take Chris’s place.” “Why not?” “Because even Chris failed at being the man she thought he was.”
Well,