Александр Алексеевич Мельчаев

Существенные нарушения в уголовном деле Предварительное расследование


Скачать книгу

"Об утверждении Инструкции о порядке представления результатов оперативно-розыскной деятельности органу дознания, следователю или в суд"

      4

      Определение Конституционного Суда РФ от 27.01.2022 N 186-О

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