Д. Р. Абгарян

Практика международного трибунала по морскому праву


Скачать книгу

Oda. Some Reflections on the Dispute Settlement Clauses in the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea // J. Macaraczyk (ed.) Essays in International Law, in Honour of Judge Manfred Lachs, 1984. P. 115.

      78

      A. Boyle. Dispute Settlement and the Law of the Sea Convention: Problems of Fragmentation and Jurisdiction//International and Comparative Law Quarterly. V. 46. 1997.

      79

      A. Boyle. Op. cit. P. 41.

      80

      Вспомогательный орган Генеральной Ассамблеи ООН, созданный для содействия кодификации и прогрессивному развитию международного права.

      81

      Report of the Study Group of the International Law Commission «Fragmentation of International Law: Difficulties Arising from the Diversification and Expansion of International Law» (Analytical Study) (2006) UN Doc A/CN.4/L.682.

      82

      Report of the Study Group of the International Law Commission «Fragmentation of International Law: Difficulties Arising from the Diversification and Expansion of International Law» (Conclusions) (2006) UN Doc A/CN/.4/L.702.

      83

      См., напр.: Alvarez J. E. International Organizations as Law-makers. OUP, 2006. Р. 259.

      84

      Shahabuddeen M. Precedent in the World Court. Cambridge University Press, 1996.

      85

      Ibid. P. 232.

      86

      Ibid. P. 86, 90.

      87

      «stare decisis» – понятие в англо-американской юриспруденции, которое означает обязанность суда учитывать принятые ранее судебные решения, благодаря чему формируется прецедент.

      88

      Oda Sh. The International Court of Justice Viewed from the Bench (1976–1993) // Recueil des Cours, V. 244. 1993. P. 144–155.

      89

      Shahabuddeen M. Precedent in the World Court. P. 8–9.

      90

      Шинкарецкая Г. Г. Указ. соч. С. 100.

/9j/4AAQSkZJRgABAQEBLAEsAAD/2wBDAAIBAQIBAQICAgICAgICAwUDAwMDAwYEBAMFBwYHBwcGBwcICQsJCAgKCAcHCg0KCgsMDAwMBwkODw0MDgsMDAz/2wBDAQICAgMDAwYDAwYMCAcIDAwMDAwMDAwMDAwMDAwMDAwMDAwMDAwMDAwMDAwMDAwMDAwMDAwMDAwMDAwMDAwMDAz/wAARCANZAjoDAREAAhEBAxEB/8QAHgABAQACAgMBAQAAAAAAAAAAAAEICQYHAgQFAwr/xABwEAABAwMBBAgCBgUGBQ0KBRUBAAIDBAURBgcIEiEJExQVMUFRkVJhCiIyQlNxYoGSoaIWIzNDdrQXOWNysRgZJDhXc4KDk7Kz0dMnNDdEZHWUldLhJSY1NlZYdLXBGik6RlR3hIaW1CpHZWZnwsT/xAAdAQEBAAIDAQEBAAAAAAAAAAAAAQYHAgQFAwgJ/8QATREAAgAEAwQGBwMJBgYBBQEBAAECAwQRBRIhBjFBURNhcYGRsQcUInKhwdEVMjUWNEJSU2KC4fAjM1SSorIkJTZzwvEIFyZDg9Jjo//aAAwDAQACEQMRAD8Aw/X6cNDX1AGEFiY5oUuOaE7SH09UKVCMmAgA8OSFBz8kIXkEHWDyCFJ4oCoB5/JAEAHNACMoCYQDx8EJqXzQoQBVM42Q8VCjHNCkCApGUOL1GeaHImEBfNW19SXtoFBcYQEJRsWGeaFKEI0EKMoS2oQoQBAEAyhBnJSwZPD/AEoLlCADkEKMIAgGMoQIUHwQlwgCBsIAhQlwEAQBCWBQoQBAEA80AyhGEKEABQBCWGMIUIRIE4QowhxzDxQ5DzQEIQDKAefieaAp9fRUnaQcioUqAIRXCAISyCCzCHIIAhGAMIUIB5oCDkUIU+CFAGEAwgHiEQIEZCoUFAEBMoC+KAICeaELjAQoKAIAEI7hChCE54Qox4KpkZfBQIYQmoIyhyCAIAMDkgCJgY5oBlAMckAQ4uwxgql1CgAQoQBAEAPMq2OKYUL1jxCrVgmPJQoKAIAgCAYygHmgCAIAqQKFJnnhAVAEBAgACAqAIB4IATyQlx4hCjxQgxzQWsMIUeCAnmgKgGcINQgBGQgIP3IcbO5TyCHIfaCAnihLlJQXHmgIEDKg3hBcg5JcIpQoyqcdQociBAVVdZLjxUKEAxzQiIcBCjPJAUeCAICePgq0RMoUKM4QDzQBAEAQBAEDCrJ2hQoQEJQj0L5IBj5oUICHmEBfNAEAQBAMc0APNAMoCfqQiY80bCGef5IUoIKAIAEAQEzzQhVdBqFCkxyQFyhLhBvGUKTyS5EioGEKEJ2DKBdYIyEKP3oAgJg5+SAqAmUJco5Ig+oI2VIICDkguXwCEYQBCgIRBAPNChAEImEKTHj80AAQl9C4/cgYHJBxCFCAIEEA80BPFUDzRsliqFJjy9EBfNAEAQEwgL5oAgCAIB4IS4QoQBAMoAgHgUAQBAEI7hCjzQDzQA+CAeKAh5fmqyajxygSKPBQtggCAAYQDPyQHl1D/gf7FXKyXQ6l/wAD/wBkplYuDA8D7D/2SlmUGB/wP9kyslx1D/gf7JlYuOof8D/ZLMAwvH3H+xTKwOof8D/YplYuh1D/AIH+xTKxcdQ/4HfsplYuOpkx9h/slmUgp5D9x/sUysly9S/4H+xSzKOof8DvZMrIBC8/cf8AslMrFx2d+PsP9lbPkQdQ/P2H/spZlHUPP3H/ALJUsyjqH/A/2TKyXQ6h/wADvZMrKOoefuP9kysgMD/gf7JlYuOof8D/AGSzA6h+fsP9imVhsdS/4H+xTKwOok+B/slmUdQ8/cd7JZkuOoePuP8AZMrF0BDIfuP/AGSlmUdQ/P2H+xSzIh1D/gf+yUs+RNB1D/gf+yUsyodQ/wCB/sUysXQ6l+PsP9kysXQ6l/wP9imVluOofj7DvZMrA6l/wP8A2SlmB1D8/Yf7FLMDqH/A/wBksyXQ6l/wP/ZKWZR1L/gd7FLMXBhePuP/AGSlmRAwP+B/sUsw2BA/P2H/ALJSzLcdQ/4H/slMrJ1jqH/A/wDZKWYuOoefuP8A2SlmUdQ/P2H+xSzA6l/wP/ZKZWS46h/wP9kysdY7O/4H+xTKxoOpf8D/ANkplYuOpfn7D/YplZLjqHj7j/2SrZ8gh2eT4X+ymVhsdQ/4H+yZWVDqH5+w79kpZluOpf8AA/8AZKWZxbHUv+B/7JSzLcdQ/wCB3slmAIX+bHfslLMo6l4+4/n+iUsxcdQ/4HeyZWB1D/gd7JlZLjqH/A/9kplZLjqX/A/9kpZlvwHUP+B/sVbMXQ6h/wAD/wBkqWYuOoefuP8AYpZi6BgkH3H+yZWLodQ/4H+xTKyjqX/A/wDZKZWccx9vJ9Su2crDiPzQEzlAMn1QDJ9UAygGUAyfVAXJKAmT6oC5JQEygGUAygBQDKAZQBAMn1QWGT6oBk+qAZPqgGUAygGT6oBk+qAZPqgGSgGUAygGT6oBlAMoBk+qAZQDJ9UAygGUAygGUAyUAyfVAVATKAZQDJQDKAuT6oCDKAZQFyfmgJk+qAZKAZQDJ9UBcn1QDP5oCZIQDOEAygBOUAQDJ9UAyfVAXJQEygGUFhlAMn1QDPzQDJQDJ9SgPx7whP8AWDK4dJDzA7wh/ECdJDzJdjvCH8QfvVzoXHeMJ8JB7FMyFx2+D8RvsUzoXHb4fxB7FTpIeYuO8IfxAmeEXHeEPxj2TPDzF2O8Icf0g9lc8PMXHeEB/rB7KdJDzFx3hD+IE6SHmLjvGDH9I396ueEo7wh/EHsUcaJfkO3w/iBFHC+IuO3w4/pB+9M6F7DvCE/1g9ioo4eYuO3w/iD2VccK4i4FwgP9YP3pnRLgV8P4g9lOkh5nId4Q/iD2TpIeZLjvCH8QeyudC47wh/EHsp0kPMo7fD+IPYpnhJcd4Qn+sCZ4eYHeEP4gVzIXAuEP4g/ep0kPMNjvCHH2wnSQ8xcdvh/EHsU6SHmLg3CH8QK50TMO8Ic/0gUzwlux2+H8QJ0kPMNg3CAf1g9imdC47fD+IPYquNIXHb4fxB7FTpIeZR3hD+IP3p0kPMDvCDH9IPZXOiXHeEP4gRxrmLjt8P4gTPDzFx2+H8QeynSQ8xcd4Q/iBM8ITHeEI/rArnQuO8IfxB7FM8IQFwh/Eapnh5i47whx/SD2VcaJcd4Q/iD2UUaZbjvCH8QfvVzwi4NwhB/pB7FTpIRcdvh/Eb+9Okh5i4Nwh/EHsU6SHmLjvCHH9IFc63C47xh8pB7JnQuDcIfxAmeElx3hCf6wJnhLcd4Q/iD2U6SHmLjvCH8QexTpIeYuO8IfjCdJDzA7whz/AEg9lVGg2DcIfxAmZEzDvCH8QJnh5luO8IPxAp0kPMajvCH8QD3TpIeYuDcIR/WD96dJDzA7wh/EH706SHmLsd4Q/iD2KueEXHeEGP6QJnQuO8IfxB+9TPDzFx3hD+IE6SHmLjvCH8QfvVzoXHeEOf6QfvTPCLjt8P4g9ipnhJcd4Q/iBM8Jbjt8PxhXMiZj5I5rrJFeg8eaIMFQAcleBEEuVIJvG4IwghWCq0cUwuJWEsAEAXJkQXE5BckcWQjPmuRLsqmg1Cly2C4lAXN2OOoXE5XCqJYDmiQYXE5DCqIxhGgmFChAArclgoUeAV3kC5WONwo2WwKiK2FCkIXJHFlRdYYV0JZhS5bBEGEYQyuJesYVQBVvoAVESwS5bDwCrIguNioLkmgwouYGMq3JYeAV0JYmMpdDUqli3YXGxR5lcmgmMriO0LlclhlAFLFuAoOAVsOA81dxN4TeNwU3FIeZVsS5VLMtwrwJxARBhBuBOFGVMJqNBjkoUIAgYVvciQx8kRR4K2IEZEFLlsxhLiwd4clUiahW5LDGVLlswuNy2CvABLiwTUJBACMhEGTB5+q5aE1LjC42LcJYJhVMlgoUYQoV4HHiCCitYmoUZdQQljkACRnBV0OOrCjZUhwnPgruAxkomSxS0geBXHeWxC0jyVURGgAScKM5DhOFyTOOUI0Bg+hXE5DB9D7IRIY+SrFgqTuGMqF4BAMEp1DegWkeRRtcCK4TgWwARgFcu0iC4FYXJ8iJDGUsUeCgQxhEgEaG8DwVTI0PNRlSGPkoUITgFd4H6lbC4wpxHAeKNhBVoDwUuLBGOoJcWACXJbUAKphoFcSgcyrYXGOagYXO5xsz9FFY5k+z5qMEJ4j4KAuQR44XLQAN5go1yAcOSjA8RhAQ/Ux5qAuctXLQBvPywiAxgKWA88eGEBDgpYFAwFYQXOFHYEJGcK8QUDCm4EIyrlBMfNEuYPLy5o0CE48sqAhyCgPIeCNA8ceB90tYHl4hcgRw5LjYAfZSwL5eq5IGzjob9wXZDt53d23za3pW13a56p1JV0GluuraulqayKmpg+doEUrWvaHRzEHhyAx3M8sa22ux2upqvo6GNpQwpxaJpNvTen1GbbO4TST6fPVQpuKJqHVp6LXc+0wd37NgLt0jez17oqOBxoLBcXz2xs+XiaikaJ6biPi4dW9rSc5Ja7nlZlgld69Qyqh74lr27n8dTGMUpPVaqOTwT07N6Nhu/LsG3WNxHYps/wBU3jYHHqaXWpbC6Ol1NW0TaeTsrZy7L5nZBJwB5LA8ErcZxKomyZdTlyc4YXxtwRl2KUuGUMmXNjkZs37zXC/MxG3CdnezPel6T636edo1jtmOrKu5PorHWVM3WUFO2klnhYJY5eMvY6MDi43AjOc55ZXjlRWUWDOb0n9rCobxJLV3SejVtb8jH8Kk01ViSl5P7OK9lrorNrVP5nZPSk2/dv3adaa/2T6Z2J1lm1haqGkktuqYb9UTwwyysgqDmnklPLqnSMyeLng48x5uzMWLVkuVWzqhOBt3hypOyut6XOz4HdxyHDqeOZSypNo0laK742e5vkZObGuiE2O7Udy+ks1bpe2Ue2+TRFLcquqprjVsmt9ZVwyupZnxOlMY4nxFrhw8JLH4A5LG6vauvk4g5kMbcjO0k0tUmrpO19z07j26fZ+km0agihSm5U970bWmlzXh0ZeyGwbYN+7RWh9c6epr1Zr1PV0Fxt9VJNEYnx000mWuiex7XskiA8cY4gQc8tgbR1c2Rhsyopo8sUNmmrc0uKejTMQwSnlzq6CTPhundNa8nytyNjNLuAbp+1beu13sFptmF20zqjTljpb3BeaK91bhNDM2PidHxyuDZI3SsHC9jmuBz5ELXrxzG5NFKxNzlFBFE1Zwreuei0duDMwWE4XNqo6FSnDEkndN8e/hcx96NToutnevtrm23/ChUyaotWxu8TWQW2jmkgbXmPrXOq5BERIW8EWGsaQC7jznhC97aPaWqlU9P6msrnJRXdna9tFfTjq+VjycFwOnjmzvWfaUt2tztfXTXgc6t+7nu0bwfRm7T9tGhtjI0xWaeorvHaO8LzWVMjX00f8ANVDmifgBPE13AeIAjB4gunFX4vS4vJw+pqMyicN7JLfvW6/edpUeGz8OmVkiTlaUVrtvdx3nCN+7dC2T7I+id2bbT9P6Es1m1prNljZW3BlbWOERqaV08zoo5J3MaXOjxzBwHOx5EdzA8UrZ+NzaObNbggz2VlwdldpdZ1cVw+llYXLqZcCUcWW7u+Ku+NjxqNz3ZRUdBY3bRHoa1t2iOtzYu9Y62rwZRdexmfquuMfGYxnHDw8RJwPBFitb+Un2f0r6O+6y/VzWva9rh4fSvBPXMiz233f61r77GuZzsFbAMPM+uhT3Odmm8bQa0uu1nT1tu1iFyt9hsMlTVVNNI+5StlkfFG6GRgdmMRnDs8yMY5rB9scXrKRy4KGNqK0UUWifsq2uqfG5lezWHU1Qo46qG6uktWtdeTOkulX3VKDdB30tR6ZsdCbfpauhp7vY4eJ72xUsrMGMOeS53BKyVuSSeQyvZ2YxOKuw+CdMd41dRdq+qseZjtBDSVkUuBWhdmux/wA7n5dFVsi0tt835tHaM1nYqPUOnNQMrYqqlnlmiwY6SW