Александр Герцен

Дилетантизм в науке


Скачать книгу

статья посвящена будет исключительно дилетантам-романтикам.

      13

      Первая статья была о дилетантизме вообще; следующая будет посвящена специализму в науке, в четвертой (если она будет) поговорим о формализме. – Писавший просит редакцию позволить ему обратить внимание читателей на важную опечатку, вкравшуюся в первую статью. На стран. 33, стр. 20-й снизу, напечатано вместо гуманнейший – туманнейший.

/9j/4AAQSkZJRgABAQEASABIAAD/2wBDAAMCAgMCAgMDAwMEAwMEBQgFBQQEBQoHBwYIDAoMDAsK CwsNDhIQDQ4RDgsLEBYQERMUFRUVDA8XGBYUGBIUFRT/2wBDAQMEBAUEBQkFBQkUDQsNFBQUFBQU FBQUFBQUFBQUFBQUFBQUFBQUFBQUFBQUFBQUFBQUFBQUFBQUFBQUFBQUFBT/wAARCAMeAjoDAREA AhEBAxEB/8QAHQAAAwEAAwEBAQAAAAAAAAAAAAECAwUGBwQICf/EAGMQAAIBAwIEAwUFBQMIAgoM DwECEQADIRIxBAVBUQYiYQcTMnGBCJGhsfAjQsHR4RRS8QkVFiQzYnKCFxgmNDZDU2NzdKK0GSU4 VFZkdYOSk5SVsrPTJyhEVYSjwjU3Rld2/8QAGQEBAQEBAQEAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAECAwQF/8QAKREB AQEAAgEEAQQDAQADAAAAAAERAjEhAxJBURMUUmFxBDIzIiNCgf/aAAwDAQACEQMRAD8A/ZhMSSJn vv8AKvQ+h2QJAnPeJo2UZidI9O9GejZ/JAEnpJFF/koGFIJOBjpQOW1EFoG8UO/LPWZjV9w3FFTr BI8oP02oGcAMT8sUDB85AiZg+tA/iIznYMNqCT5R5AYGx3k0AfIdUSe/Wgi66yBkY3GKAnWcHVmf woCdWkjHWDQBXzmIUrtmr0IYjIwTWhYaD67VnsTEHUsqQNgavQkuImSBvvU7XATJklQpgY3qoUap Az+EVQiJIIBUd9o+dANpEkdN5mKAjQuwyJz1/pQLUBAO5E+pNRYz9551aCIGR60KZJkaiTJgVUIF g2cgdY+tF+FRIBmDuQOtEBjqYHRZwRQZi4VaFiI23o0F8klgGU9RtvRO0h2KSQROJPeihZJgGNyO 570DeLZA3kiSPzoCZnBAAoIZBq1Fc+lBJYsjQArHHckUCJ0KAQMRviN6CyCwYlhO+RRCJEHyicGj TONMwfLEEdqFpEsB+IBoBVVlXSYIGCe9AODpAO89pJoIZhJwdPfai9FrBUE5k5omjVsHYCTIJ/Kg DqGraRnfFAtRbKjcTGaLiXcwoyqjJI3ovhJJz5fMMROaAdoQxP8AdK7xQEKrTkKJljt9KCbgzAZQ 5khTRUyDqIwZyfWiDUQwDfdAz/WgCTjVE9yZ+tBMsBiDnGIk0XNSurWPUTq6xRQ2kL0Yk7kfqKMp XL6sET+ooHJuBpyCNXc/SgGAG42jfrRrpLEBpJxv2iiBmhkDgEdo+6iEWNsDJOJzGaDNma4rAT3j 60bw2BCEknWeoG3rRNULzAAC7iiO6q3lIIaRjasOAk9QD9djRTXzY6/hRCYxgbzg0RHvIid9tUbC jREZkz1yeooESG2OTmIzQMHSqjcneenrQT0iQV2+tBYyDBGpqCZLCMk/lQEQw3MRMUEMx1BQY04J PSgIgwCFOfpQJQIMH0q0SQx0yIAMb52pBXu/ITgjYwaaGRBMHJH0NIJ1eYGfhHSnYnUXyNOBB7A0 wSXQbflWgySQojcbztQSADBkDp6igs4Mb77daCWdQhwJA2I+6oEzvp1HygCBjIqhHTJGVnINBIYR p1HH50FBARHUnAJxQJYI0kwBtpoIdlUAxkYJB39aiwrjYSZ1Z23P0pAjvqIBA7HJqqGAglQYB2Mi TROiDwoDSBtv1oYZYIZwC3m/pQ7QT+1LYxgwNqKkvlguwzkmgqDIkkkdSd6A8pYEnP8AdB/jQIqB J3BOy5oRm3lVgSSGO1FCxEfu99qICFBMkj0GaAEtGGIGw2n0oEHmRAAA1Rjei4zLkgw0Z2B2ooJI gSMCTPSjJlgVlW0jrBoqT+0Uas/8O4os/gtSRJGP1+FCROrzZkE4gGipEzqADdiTkUFET0BK5Get BJH7MwxIO8DJoJusTggwP1ih0mBuqlmX91tyKG/anQDIIC/3TQIQFkkKJ69O1ApAgRGP3hRrpBAV cuZPc7fyomjSqYGoMek7URMKkggA+pxI60DOJEgMABvH4UXEFhagT5ehjrRdAYEaNIBIkzmDRkFd GreZGd/uoInzaVzJ6n8KNYQkgEDzTGRgUOjJYk7MRt3n0onaAwXT5yyn9RTDALjR8ZPrH9KGO9yN u2ZrDgUAGYAg/MUBmSAQczg0EyWkGc9skUVBnQQcbwO5oBZZQpB2yaCiIWIzQNdUzEkYzgighjJG wE9BtQVE3Phn0ojMIDAiN9jV1UFy7Nrz6HpTBeNBliq/LcfxoJgBSIDCBB3pgFy2oLMGSP41QwzE wYwNpqBRBJJPaTQQxJLeWB3iqE2F3+cd6AIDgH4RuV/rVEsJ09hQWYD5iMzFAugkZjbsKCWMKR22 Db/WsriDrYxhWHbpVQixUloYNVFEgrM57gzFBJIVI/dO0UCICqu8ADczQIvqBkAAdqLhsAGAOW6A 7iggRqgCTGY/h2oasA3NzIwc7UKksNR0kBG+6gksCPKNPeigkaADH8xUEwFAzK7YqhsuAPMAomPl QNnCsYST3nY0RkWxpY6JEDE4ouBgQI1eudqDMNOTMCZXpRTYFRGT9Jog1gRqwJ1esUUiepkCTkbf Oi5gDAIZIBnHr60TtCsCAWE9cn9YoLMqBhTPbEURM6WJaCtFQRIIbYjcHc0XpGSCd/Q7mino2IaV 7Lv60ErbUFmBgdoxQNiI+GCe/T/GgQ+MhZmMY2oaQYadMEgbE9aBLbZrhaSTESRuaCNTIFYYjv0o uAsWAXUSYznrRdSZtsupQD8zntRkmcox6kxpMb0FMsLBbUZ+QoqCC06fgJzA/jRehLB9RAEdhRDw 6SW9SSNqIg+VvTT0zJouExEwGhckQMf1oqHjyFkA2nSKLqlhiqnO52jbajCbRX3bEzjInr/OioLH WGKiDEiPuNGjlzmN/UUR3lQCukYkb1hwDFW0gNPTVvFEZg5nJ3oqicETB6QcUEghmmd8TJoG2D0U xvNAwVRcnOwI2oERgjMb6qBMZx1B670EszMdIIgHf0oEcgD4fU0DImAJPSetUBb4sgmDkUCSSRDH PcdatDwAAfxrIHnQBM46UEMcZx0xVkEAHGJI3A/OtAYhSQQQQML0M0DkqYJk4ImgD55GTJ2G1AmY BTkzOQTUEB2dj5D9KL0DhmMAEfvflREAhvMAfKZM9KotoJIBLQJk0AJ0kfu9cZPoaCbhZCAokqdz /GiyEzayWLSc4XpQSigmSII9aB419z0ahACdUwQRiO386Kg3ArBo8pxt3oZU6g66SRJxA2/Ch10S hgDDEnaJ3j/CgNfnGoQc4FAzkzIwOnWgTHQCBBzOMkfzoZqWcSGkgkwJ796KUDAyR8WcTRCExJYT iMUUBgXBE9fp3oiSCpIJgAyI/lRcTqJExBmMCM0FPHbI/emhqXuQNJ39BFANp0+U9NOBvQSbkoNI mTDDr9KNYRUaswF3gSJompDQTiTsT2optKjUQSx/GgRJEQFEbdJoYljqBBME7CMCi9JRZWTkEzje iADO2gxsw6UEhgxUMW0mMHGKBF4Tyy2difWjRBiRgDbCntRNMiAUkSdp9KIksYXzNIxJoCQ7grA+ kT60aRkkY8/Un+FDVEK2/wBKMpDESAQkE+cUEkMAIMDvE0aTsCRLZmRuRQSSNIKmGjAG0+lBLbrJ ydwSR+NEaFjOCDAkMD0oqCFRvh84wfNJoqUkEHzAzOKoZUE7kekDFQd5nVq2DAVh5w2SRAxGPX1o IzMZ6D/Cg8+9s3ts5P7FuV8u4vm/C8Vxzcdea1a4fgigeFXUzeYgQJA7ywpHL1PUnp5rvHK+Psc6 5dwfH8LcF7hOMspxFu4OqOoZfwNV0l2a+wlUYACDUUp8qqDJjeIigksU1Hb5igzb4wSCfWgpjDQD E7dx8qsgmdRgmWH7w6VUWg1CMkA7TmoJLDYsIjqdjT4CwCTBIAwJxVUO0gGB9aglWBAGQPToauAV yTkRAnOxNKEF1EwIB6Ab1QislZzp7CiKFzqBk4noaiul+1T2kWPZX4N4nxFe4C7zC1YuWrXuLTi2 za20zJkCKOfqcvx8fdXiifbg4K6AyeCObup2ZeIUj/8AAo836qfT3/wV4mHjLwpynna8Nc4NeP4V OKHD3jL2gw+EmBkUerjy93GcnNJ5QcnJkVW6bLAMkAzvigSnSSek4H63qCbhlfPDLPfp61VBUEmT EY8tDyll8rkEEAdKGlEahMYkntQ8BWCqSSMbgiAKHSSwGQOm5FFTkKQPMPhgUEtgjeRvMUFatMCC ZEwaACkgEQG3/wAaABkhRtt3AoJwGE9N5NDUYVoLf7xMYoK1ecqTkZJiaAYwrTKgnpQS90QFHkAz MxNFwmgqpgLnvihqCGInJ6AHGf0KAKhpho6A+lBTnQ8R5ugGaKguCo1SBq+VF6Q9ySCMgn7jQMNq JM+UdGG39KJhaQIYnAJBI2HyoG1wgwraD/eJn7qLIzgsdSnWgyCuCTQ0MFuiNgc0EwCYBlDk5/P8 aBMRbcgT2n060XBcl4yBqGaBFiGhduxAJ9DREOhKwpP379c0FC6AZLTuSIoM7rMcsAYjc0a6GnUu rJAO3aiWoLDUAFleoNEavIAYmABtM/SgzuqBLErpBiCQaNYnITBIEyOxG9CkWAaVEIehGDnegcQQ cqOhJn8KJ5SblwYK5gkE/rtRrE7loAEDc7xQSymyVYajJzt2qg0kR8S9DJmngbqPKMJ9d6g7mfMu CQO5rDzhdUaSBvQLWFneTkGg/H/tg5ff9vP2g+beG+Dm/wAJ4a5JxSppML/aRbLT8zda2v8Ay1fh 871f/k9TJ8PTPsc+N/8ASr2RWuWcQ5bjeRXjwbK3xe6PntE/IFl/5KV3/wAfl7uGfThfa17VPaTY 9uVjwL4Eu8ua7e5fb4lbXH2rcFtLu5NxyABC7VP5Z9Tnznqezgv7PPtk8YeLvGHjLk/jPiuC08i4 Yl/7Lw6Ktt0ulLh1L8QAU/nVw9L1OVtnP4cR4b9qHth9u3Gc34/2e2eU8n8Pcvve5s/5wUNc4hol V1FWlysEgBVGoAmnTP5PU9S32dPv8PfaO5/4k9hPjbnr8Pw3L/F3hopaulbOqy7M6qG92Tg/GCsx IkVVnrcr6fLl8xxnMftKeI+H9jPg67wZscf7QPEnEXLfD2rXDjSEW+1vV7sYloVAO+o9KqcvWvsl +a7R7bPbF4k9jfgjw1yw3OF5x465spS5fXhwLNthAcpbHxeZwig7wSe1Rv1PV5enxk+a5P2Wcs9t 3DeKuBfx1zHlHE+H7lp24ixY9yeIsvHkTyKsGdyCwEGovp/l3/104nxTyr7QTcXzPjOC8ReFuV8u tPdfhOHAQPesqSVPmtuAxUDdhneKazy/P5vw+T2be3zn3jT2A+M/EfEDhrXiLw/ZuBb9uyBbut7s PbYptOSCNsTiri8PV5cvTt+Y5z2U+1bnPiv2Bc18U804ng/892E49rbJZVEm0pNvyTnbPejXD1Ly 9P3Xt932YPaPzn2pez3iOb+Ib1i7xlvmFzh9ViyLI92EtnYf8RzSr6PO8+O8njHLPb17ZfEnh/xV 4k5Ovh9+RchuOOLu3uGtpcVBJGlC8udMbdaPN+b1bLZ8PUPB/tc8Rc7+zPznxtxVzhRz7hrXGXLT 2+HC2gbT6U8k9vXNV34+pyvpXn8+XReS+0j24+03wE3ifw83JuW8By626XRoT3/MbtsE3GtoysAA MaZWSDBJqOU5+tznu4/D1T7Oftb4v2w+BL3HcwSzb5rwXEf2bijYGm3clQyOF/dkHI7g0ej0fU/J x29uL+13q/6DeazGeM4Qz/8AO0Z/yP8Am7T9nLirw9h/gxF4i6oHLxCq7KPibpNMa9GT8cdP9s/t o8Tct8fco8AeBuDscX4q5iq3LnEcYNaWA2ogRMfCpcs2wjBJo5+r6t42cOHbiPD3tS9ovgH2t8l8 Fe0f/NvMLXPE/wBU4/lqadJMhT8KyNS6SCoIkEEiicfU58eft5/LiLnth9pvij2qeMvAvhheUe+4 Ti7o4fj+NtBE4Lh7bQzPg62OpFGDnoehn8nqXneHFyXsf9sPjfhPbFxPs59oB4XjeOZWNni+HVV8 wT3ggqAGRkkgwCCPnRv0vV5+/wBnNyHsA9qniPx97QPHXKedcZav8Dyi4RwqW+HW2VH9odMkZPlU DNGvS9Tlz58pfhfsS9qPiLxr7WfHnIua8XZvct5TcccIi2FQpHEFBLD4vKOtVPS9Xly53jXBcN7W faZ7aPGPPOWezVOVcs5Lyd/dvzDmSajdOoqpkq0FirEKF2Ek1GPy+p6nKz0+n3+z/wBuvibnPhX2 icu59wvDcH4x8KcHfuG7ZQe6dkDiWSYlXXMYII2o1w9Xly48t7jl/Yn7U+c+OPY7zPxBzniuFfm1 m7xgtlLS2lAt2gyeWc5P1qunpepeXC8q1+zF7Sufe1XwVzDmXP71i7xVjjv7OjcPZFldHukaCBuZ Ymh6HqX1ONvJ7CMp104jNHpIAlxI6yKFJjJX94gyCcYoIf4iG2OSs4o10RhUGZIj5iiACYjJ6A70 Qaisgt2g9aAe5oWEI2kqKLJ9pLE+Zh5oGBQIKWA1Quk7Rj7utBPxT0bY9xRFBfMDqOoZg0VmXllM FRMd5osgYENKkA74G0d6BHzAnJxHzoqCPKJMkmfpQN9aqTIgjyzmiwtm0loBGVFEJZXTuc99qAXA AGGUyAaA6SB5uqjvQIsFBUGAPmZ7g0GesMdQXpAB70XRBcbmZiOgohnVJM/KenegyNyGIbImdR/l RrFC6RqAaNUxREQJhNmjyg79zQ1bWSIZRJE7nzGiJDQywIPUtmKNSMySoJ67QcTQSFKAHExJnpRN VpAYY0hvMTJ7UOyD+U7A+p6UaQY1EgsYEyDuKBXQpEsQRHfP0ogQFV1FCcQPL+M1VZnVbY5BGCO3 yNPgaPqUDzGTIwNqgn3bn9/8AauL4d6Uw2mAARAMzXN5gSGY5Bn76DhvGXiex4L8Lc359xpHuOXc Lc4k/wC8VEqvzJgfWqzy5e3ja/HvsF9k/tH8ccr5n448PeOLPhLiOacZdS87WrjXeJKvrZpVT5db ER3U03HzfT4epy/9cbjb2R8x4r7OPt8594f8T8fbv8LxvBPdvcZaUi3eYIb9u6qmDn9osdyRV7jX p38XO8eTtvsR52vti+014j8fcDZvf5j4Dgl4Xh7t5dLSyrbQGJhiouNHQGjp6d/J615zpxfsC5ee ee1z23cttOou8bY4zhlJOAz8RcUT9TRj0pvPnI8+9iPKfZ1wvC855N7Rucc78Mc84Hiigt2OYXuF tMAArKVRT51ZTvEgiNqeXP05w8zlcep8y5J7O+XfZq9pnHezzjeL47geIKWuLvcbeZ295buW4jUq kAh5kjMzT+3b28J6XL2XXlHKfDnN/Zh7O/Avte8NcTdu3lu3uH5havEXLdoe/dE0gjy23UFD1DGQ Rqp8uE43hxnqR3r7T/iC34jsey72ncotni+SAAGDPu7q3Uui05/daVdfmpo6+tfd7ec6e4ck+0h4 O8c8VZ5V4b5k/E+IOP4e9d4Xgr3DOh96ttnCMSAJkRAJmpj1T1uHLxO35W8A+KfBfiYeIb3tSXn/ AIm8aX7/ALrgOXrcvnXcKkC2qIQFf3mNLQAAABvVeDjePLfyW67V7DUHD/Zl9sFi75OJtC8l5GwU YWAII6GQ33UdfT/5c3F+zD7PPhvxt7DeZ+NOO47mlrmXC2+OZLXD3bQsH3CkpIKFsxnP3UY4ejOX D365j2Me1ngvZV9mjmfF3vevx/MeZ8Zw3ALaTUpv/wBntEaj+6BMz6RRv0/UnD0vLrvgL2oeDPC/ 2bPFfha/zS63ifnKcQ3uF4ZympgqW1NyI+FZmcaqrPDnx4+neNvmu0eyvxxyvmP2VfG/hew1xua8 u5fxnF3w1uEFu7d8mlup7jpRv0+Uvo8uP0+j2J+3bwl4A9gnF8r4/mRHPbL8Y1vlyWXL3DcJ0Q0a YMiSTiDRfT9Xjw9PL35d1+xP4W4zkfsy5hzPi7TWU5txgu8MGUjXaRAmsehbVB7CaN/43HONrm/t ewnsM5oWaP8AW+EyT/4yjfr/APN2L7OpV/Yh4MIyP83rmcfG1Rr0f+ceAfaF5Fy3kf2keV848WNz Cx4V5tw9pX4zl91rV1Cls22CuomVOlioyVajy+tJPU3l1XbvA3hz2I8X7SfD68g8Qc1514jtO3E8 EOI5ldv2w1tS0NrQepCzmKeXTjx9L3zOW11DwP4+5F7PftR+0XjvEHMF5bwfEXOL4dL7ozLr98jQ dIMYU9KrHHlx4etyvL+XK+zjmFv2wfa64nxbyZLtzkHKbQLcVctlAwFn3NuQdi7EkA5hSaLwv5PX 906dX9ivta8Neyr2pe0PifEXE3rFrjeKuWrJsWTdJZeJuM0gbYIqMel6nH0+fL3Pt+zj7R+Q8P7c /Fr3eIu+78TcQ1jl7LZJ1lr7ONX9zy5zVPR5z8l/l1b2Y+HPBPhzxh4p8N+0rmXNvD3HcLfC8Pe