Природа человека. С комментариями и объяснениями. Дэвид Юм

для того чтобы больше приспособить свой язык к обычному словоупотреблению, мы должны разделить аргументы на демонстративные доказательства, доказательства из опыта и вероятности, подразумевая под доказательствами из опыта такие основанные на опыте аргументы, которые не оставляют места сомнению или противоположному тезису. – Здесь и далее примечания приводятся по изданию: Юм Д. Сочинения: в 2 т. М.: Мысль, 1995 (Философское наследие).

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