spiritual truth should be consistent.
But my observations countered these notions: Some of these people were suffering due to their own stupid mistakes and bad judgment, like me. But others had bad things happen to them, through no obvious fault of their own. Still others suffered due to the foolish mistakes of thoughtless friends, relations, or strangers. Examples of innocent people killed by texting or drunk drivers, come to mind.
At the time I believed this theory of spiritual reciprocity due to its biblical foundation. It is a popular American theology. So I thought that if I was honest, worked hard, and tried to ethically please God and man, I would be rewarded. I also believed that circumstances that presented themselves to me had to come to me as pre-approved by God the Father. As a result, I took seriously the critiques of the people I loved. When someone was critical of me, I took it seriously and sought self-improvement or correction. As in the case of my previous marriage(s) the charge made against me was that I didn’t make enough money. I held the naive belief that ‘if only I was good enough’ for the other person, things would be okay.
In truth, although I worked hard, was honest, lived a life of faith, and approached others with compassion and sincerity, I never could increase my material circumstances. I tried the tithing formulas, but these didn’t work as advertised. Strangely enough to this day I still cannot get a pastor to tell me whether or not a tithe is based upon the net or the gross of a person’s income. If you use the Abrahamic formula it is gross; but if you render unto Ceasar first, it is net. But no one will say for sure.
What they do say is that ‘he who sows little, reaps little, and he who sows much, reaps much’. And they point to the promise of a return that is “pressed down, shaken together and running over” from Luke 6:38. This is the common theme of the spiritual-reciprocity evangels, and although it may be true for some, it is not systemically applied to all the children of God. And it has been painfully obvious that these axioms of spiritual-reciprocity fail to fit in my situation.
Principles of spiritual-reciprocity also failed to fit those I knew who were dying of cancer, lost their jobs, stepped out in faith in business ventures that went sour, lost investments, had been injured in accidents, or were raped or robbed. They also didn’t quite fit with those who were later to return from the various wars: friends I knew who served in Vietnam, the Gulf War, and vets I had met who lost limbs (or worse) from the current, so-called ‘war on terror’.
Through these failures I was compelled to do more self-examination. I did not – and do not—doubt Jesus at His word that He came to give us an Abundant Life. So if He is not wrong, I must be. I concluded that I had mistakenly connected this “Abundant Life thing” to the kind of happiness known to those who are materially comfortable. Even further than this, I concluded that what I was really seeking from God was to avoid all manner of suffering.
Being honest with myself, I had to conclude—yes, that was it. I was tired of being poor, being kicked, and generally tired of this old sinful world. I was not necessarily envious of others, per se. I didn’t want someone else’s life, wife, home, car, or money. But I did want to earn my own, make it on my own, be a success, and thereby be a benefit to my community and not a burden to others.
I decided that to know my true motivations and to stay honest with myself, I had to study “suffering”.
Back I went to various denominations and Bible teachers who mostly pointed me to the Book of Job as the source of all information regarding the topic of suffering. But these studies did not reveal the answers I was looking for. The Book of Job is a great descriptive narrative that talks “about” suffering, but not suffering.
In Job, suffering is represented as part of a cosmic struggle between God and Satan, where Satan is given permission to make Job’s life a living hell to include the killing of his kids.
For me the Book of Job did not answer the question as to why these things happened. Job’s three closest advisers kept telling him that his problems stemmed from the sin in his life. And some would draw a parallel to the people I know [or myself] and allege that our sufferings were due to sin. But the Book of Job itself disputes this claim, as the text clearly shows that Job’s three friends were proven wrong in their allegations against Job. This same notion that ‘suffering comes from a judgment of sin’ was discounted by Christ Himself where in John 9:2 Jesus was asked ‘who sinned that this man was born blind’? Or when Christ spoke about the Tower of Siloam in Luke 13:4-5.
What I did learn from the Book of Job was that 3 out 4 of your ‘smart’ friends will give you the wrong answers.
So from all of my religious sources, rather than helping, these kinds of “answers” were no answers at all. Indeed, they were quite the opposite, since they could only be acceptable to people for whom the tithing formulas worked, or the prayer formulas resulted in ‘answered prayers’ in the affirmative, or whose outcomes reinforced the lifestyles of people who were already comfortably situated.
Through the worst of these times, though, I did discover that God was a faithful companion. As bad as things got, I felt He was ever with me. But to be perfectly honest, even though I could feel His Presence, I still responded to Him with a sarcastic “thanks for nothin’, buddy” — because the suffering went on.
And I wanted to know: If I am saved, if I am your child, if I am doing my best to follow your Word, then why are You doing this?
And His response was persistent: “If any of you lacks wisdom, you should ask God…” James 1:5. So…I asked. I asked a lot. And I kept asking.
In the late 1990s I was introduced to studying Old Testament theology by a renowned biblical scholar, professor of Old Testament, and one of the original translators of the New International Version who happened to live in the San Diego area.
It was this man who fundamentally shifted my thinking with regard to the Word. His response to my probe regarding ‘knowing the Scriptures’ was his Socratic answer: “Can a man really know anything?” This seemingly trivial trick-question penetrated my mind and set me on a course to understand the origin of Information. The Origin of Information is a geeky topic and not within the scope of this book, but its study led to a greater connection of dots that assisted in an expanded view of the Almighty, which became essential to the understanding of everything else. This book is not long enough to express the depth of understanding I was able to acquire by this learned professor.
My next best teacher became another well-published professor of New Testament and an expert in hermeneutics and Bible translation.
Both of these men consistently demonstrated how a single verse of Scripture can be accurately interpreted in different ways with different meanings when contextually overlaid with the templates of directed audience, time period, literary type, grammatical structure, historical context, personal spiritual relevancies, --and more.
My third best teacher became the writings of the now deceased A.W. Tozer. It was Tozer’s expositions on the attributes of God and the workings of the Holy Spirit that finally gave rise to a compositional understanding of the role of suffering.
These “three wise men” arranged the intellectual building blocks that allowed my mind to grasp what the Spirit was revealing to my soul:
There is a connection between God’s expressions of His Love and the expressions of His Own Suffering.
[I should note here that my assertions and conclusions expressed in this book do not necessarily reflect those of these three men or any church or seminary.]
I have finally reached a conclusion about the “Abundant Life”.
The “Abundant Life” that was promised, “pressed down, shaken together and running over” is not made of the currency of this world, but rather the currency of heaven. And what is the ‘currency’ of heaven? It is the Holy Morality of God-- and that same divine morality is linked to His and our physical and spiritual suffering.
There is little separation between the Abundant Life and the command to take up your cross and follow Jesus. To “take up your cross“ is not a glib phrase. It is a mandate to engage in an intimate fellowship