on water, food and air as though denied his proper nutriment on this earth.”
O, it was impossible, but impossible, to tell it! Words made everything worse. Nothing ever hit the mark.
“What about women? Did he court? Have affairs?” Irving asked.
Clark shook his head. Always looking in the wrong places, these sleuths.
“Every woman loved Lewis, and no woman did,” Clark said. “For how does one love what is not there? I sometimes think we made him up. He represents something we want in the world, and his own ideas about himself be damned!”
“Court-martialed for dueling,” Irving said. “Advocated the slaughter of the Arikara Nation.” Reading from his notes.
“Acquitted of any wrongdoing,” Clark said. “And wrote the Indian policy that restricted white settlement to the Missouri’s shore.”
“Did you never suspect Neelly, who turned up later with Lewis’s guns? Or his valet, Pernia, who showed up actually wearing his clothes?” the upstart asked.
“No, never,” Clark said. “But then, I knew him. Never was there a better.”
“He had enemies, though,” Irving said, flipping back through the pages of his notebook toward the start.
“None so formidable as himself,” Clark said. “If he thought it were better to die to bring about a better age, to hasten its coming, he might die.”
“I have something here about a Mandan chief—Big White, was it?—who was literally years getting home from Washington,” Irving noted.
“A sad case,” Clark said. “By the time he was back, nobody believed he’d lived in a marble city filled with white people. Lately, he is said to doubt it himself.”
“What of Janey?” Irving asked.
Clark looked across with a jerk of his chin, then a casual recrossing of his gouty, swollen, tender legs. “Dead these twenty years,” he said.
“Her son and daughter?”
“The son a lawyer, briefly, now is a mountain guide. Her daughter dead from fever.”
“The husband, then?”
Clark’s head and feet pained him with the coming rain. “O, lively as he ever was and drawing a handsome pension at the Mandan Indian Bureau, God help us.”
“Anything more you wish to add?” Irving asked, looking disappointedly through the meager notes.
“Only that Janey’s dying, and Theodosia’s vanishing with her ship and crew, and the great comet and earthquake of a generation ago all coincided with the murder of George, Lilburne’s butter-fingered slave,” he said. “Several years ago, the second and third presidents of our country expired together, on the precise day of the fiftieth anniversary of our union.”
“What can that mean?” Irving asked.
“Nothing,” Clark said, and waited for the demonstrated effect. Perhaps now he would go away. Perhaps now they’d all go away and let him die. “A pity about your bad reviews,” he added.
Irving could not meet his eye. “Yes, thank you. No life is without its painful reflections,” he said. “But what of this rumor, by the way, that your slave York is in fact not dead but has made of himself a Crow chief in the Colorado territory?”
“He is dead,” Clark said firmly. “Of yellow fever in Tennessee. But write it any way you wish.”
“Do you think your friend ever had any lover? What about Burr’s daughter, this Theodosia?”
Clark sighed and peeled dead skin from his thumb’s pad. “Write it however you wish.”
“What about the girl? The interpretess?” Irving asked. His lamp-lights now glowed full hot as he regarded Clark and a red, like burns, wounded both his cheeks.
“Impossible. And if you write that, I’ll sue,” Clark said.
Irving seemed poised toward one more inquiry, but was warned by Clark’s tipping his chin down an additional degree as if to reach out and seize him. Which he would do, Clark feared, and with a strange cry, too, a hysteric sob. It seemed he had, in some way, become Lewis after his death, as though the absence of one required he play both parts.
“I do sometimes think the president was a kind of diabolic rationalist, a madman of empiricism,” Clark said. “And Lewis his re-animate creature.”
Clark felt it clearly, at last, that same helpless hysteria that Lewis must have known, the wish to get up and shove this Irving over in his chair. He was at last starting to see exactly how mad Lewis had been, and in which directions. “So what did really happen between you and Mrs. Shelley?” he asked suddenly.
“Nothing at all. We met one night at the opera. But I saw something there, back of her eyes, and chose not to investigate,” Irving said.
“You should know that my servant York was a very great dissembler, shape-shifter, and liar. A regular Baron Münchhausen. He probably started that Crow chief story himself.”
“We will never know,” Irving said, noting something on his little “reporter’s” pad.
“I freed the fellow, and then he has the nerve to return to me later and damn his freedom to my face, saying it is nothing of the sort, and worse than his shackles had been,” Clark said. “Imagine the cheek!”
“You were Lewis’s dearest friend,” Irving said abruptly. “Did you feel responsible?”
Clark lurched inside and fleered sideways, but outwardly knew he appeared unfazed and innocent of even the faintest blush. The room tried to turn over on its edge, then righted itself. Irving shewed no sign of having seen. “One always wishes to have done one more thing for a dead friend,” he said. It was this Irving’s last attempt to unseat him, last and best, and had failed, Clark was fairly convinced.
Irving paused over a lengthy note to himself. The mantel clock ticked off the instants left until death.
“One felt responsible for Lewis,” Clark added, taking himself by surprise. “And wished to be like him and liked by him. Without the help of others, and guidance and temperance, he would perish, one felt fairly sure. He blundered blindly toward great things, and believed you’d help him, and e’en depended on ’t. He saw our potential, but fought back despair brought on by keen, sensitive perception of the problem and its scope.”
Irving wrote that. They both listened to the clock. “Are you familiar with Gulliver’s Travels?” Irving asked.
“Yes,” Clark said, looking up. “I seem to recall . . . early in our journey . . .”
“Those people believed that Gulliver’s watch was his god because he was constantly checking its face, as if for reassurance,” Irving said.
Clark waited for a point, then understood that was it.
“What about the all-water route?” Irving asked.
“For all we know, it is still out there, waiting for discovery. And the Northwest Passage, too,” Clark said.
“Do you truly think that?” Irving asked, pen paused.
“I am not certain that I ever did think it, or that it mattered to me,” he said, looking upward for the answer. “My friend asked me to join him, in triumph or in ruin.”
He was at last pleased by something he had said in the interview, and resolved to end it.
“Or both,” Irving said.
“Or both,” Clark concurred.
“Do you know,” Irving said, “that an angel of the Lord has recently appeared to a man in upper-state New York on four separate occasions? And that he has found, buried in the woods, some heretofore unknown