Йохан Арнасон

Цивилизационные паттерны и исторические процессы


Скачать книгу

С. 20–31.

      4

      Skirbekk S. Dysfunctional Culture: The Inadequacy of Cultural Liberalism as a Guide to Major Challenges of the 21st Century. Lanham (Maryland): University Press of America, 2005.

      5

      The Castoriadis Reader. Oxford: Blackwell, 1997.

      6

      Eisenstadt S. The Civilizational Dimension in Sociological Analysis // Thesis Eleven. 2000. Vol. 62. P. 1–21.

      7

      Arnason J. The Soviet Model as a Mode of Globalization // Thesis Eleven. 1995. Vol. 41. P. 36–53. Ее перевод см. в настоящем сборнике. – Прим. ред.

      8

      Перевод статьи: Arnason J. Civilizational Patterns and Civilizing Processes // International Sociology. 2001. Vol. 16. № 3. P. 387–405. Первая русская публикация: Неприкосновенный запас. 2014. № 6. Перевод переработан для данного издания.

      9

      Starobinski J. Le mot «civilisation» // Le temps de la réflexion. 1983. Vol. IV. P. 13–51.

      10

      Ibid.

      11

      Подробнее см.: Arnason J. Civilizations in Dispute. Leiden: Brill, 2003.

      12

      Elias N. The Civilizing Process: Sociogenetic and Psychogenetic Investigations. Oxford: Blackwell, 2000.

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