Освобождение животных. Питер Сингер

рассматривающих проблемы морали и равноправия, можно привести R.M. Hare, Freedom and Reason (New York: Oxford University Press, 1963) и John Rawls, A Theory of Justice (Cambridge: Harvard University Press, Belknap Press, 1972). О важной договоренности, достигнутой по этому вопросу между представителями разных позиций, см. R. M. Hare, «Rules of War and Moral Reasonin», Philosophy and Public Affairs 1 (2) (1972).

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