point of view because 1) they do not safeguard the relationship among the divine Persons within the Trinity, 2) each of the Persons is Creator, Redeemer, and Sanctifier, and 3) such a doxology only emphasizes God’s relationship with us and not God’s eternal nature as the Divine Community of Love.
However, it is important to note that Fathers and Doctors of the Church gave voice to their praise of God in terms beyond the traditional “Glory be.” St. Theophilus of Antioch was the first to use the term “Trinity” around AD 180. The text is Ad Autolycus 2.15, in which he has “God, His Word and His Wisdom.” The relationality is preserved but in English the possessive pronoun is masculine; see also Clementine Homilies 16.12 where Spirit is also feminine Wisdom. St. Gregory of Nazianzus
(† 389), a Doctor of the Church who was acclaimed as “the Theologian” by the Orthodox Church, praises God as “Mind and Word and Spirit, one in relationship and divinity.”12 Such a doxology is appealing to me because it is gender neutral. However, the metaphors are intellectual and abstract. Furthermore, for a book of prayer such as this, the feminine side of God should be celebrated in the doxology. In fact, St. Aphrahat († ca. 345), another Father of the Church, wrote: “Glory and honor to the Father and to his Son and to his Spirit, she who is living and holy; let the mouths of everyone render praise, above and below, for ever and ever, Amen.”13 Such a conception in the Syrian Church is refreshing. Nevertheless, as shall be seen, the Doctor of the Church St. Ephrem the Syrian († 379) depicted all three divine Persons as feminine. Moreover, according to the Ecumenical Councils, all three Persons are equal; whatever is ascribed to one is equally ascribed to the other, except for their terms expressing origin of relationship. If a doxology is to be truly theologically balanced, all three Persons must be equal, i.e., all three masculine, or all three feminine, or all three neuter.
Thus after the section of the Psalms and Scriptures you will find a list of possible doxologies you can employ, many based off of early church writings and some created by myself. In no way is this list to infer that I consider the traditional doxology as incorrect or theologically problematic; the issue is, however, pastoral. It will be up to the reader or praying community to decide which form will be used. If Praying—with the Saints—to God Our Mother is used publicly, I suggest that the first line of the doxology be recited only by the one leading the prayer; the refrain “as it was in the beginning
. . .” can be a communal response, thus avoiding confusion concerning which wording is being adopted. Of course, one is free to alternate the various doxologies between the morning and evening office or after each psalm.
May this book of prayer and meditation deepen your relationship with the God of our ancestors, and may She abundantly bless you as you prayerfully ponder another rich and life-giving facet of the Holy Trinity.
Stand firm, then, brothers and sisters,
and maintain the traditions that we taught you,
whether by word of mouth or by letter.
—2 Thessalonians 2:15
You must remain faithful to what you have learned and firmly believe;
knowing full well who your teachers were,
and how, ever since you were a child,
you have known the Holy Scriptures—
from these you can learn the wisdom
that leads to salvation through faith in Christ Jesus.
All Scripture is inspired by God
and useful for instruction and refuting error,
for guiding people’s lives
and teaching them to be upright.
This is how someone who is dedicated to God
becomes fully equipped and ready for every good work.
—2 Timothy 3:14–17
1. For a good survey of the history of Christian prayer see Taft, Liturgy of the Hours as well as Uspensky, Evening Worship.
2. See Myers, I and II Esdras, 131–34.
3. See Stuhlmueller, “Apocrypha,” 1:552.
4. See Metzger, “Fourth Book of Ezra,” 1:523.
5. See Isaac, “I Enoch,” 1:8.
6. Vatican II, “Decree on Ecumenism,” §17, p. 466.
7. According to reports coming out of Rome, Pope Benedict XVI will declare Hildegard of Bingen a Doctor of the Church in October 2012. When this happens, she will be the fourth female Doctor of the Church.
8. See Albright, “Names Shaddai and Abram.”
9. See Cross, “Yahweh and the God of the Patriarchs.”
10. See Walker, “New Interpretation.”
11. See Basil of Caesarea, De spiritu sancto 1.3 & 29.71 (PG 32:72B–C & 200B–201A).
12. See Gregory of Nazianzus, Oratio 12.1 (PG 35:844B).
13. See Aphrahat, Demonstrationes 23.61 (PS 2:128).
Scriptural Readings and Doxologies
Select Psalms in Greek as Used by the Apostles
Psalm 1
1. Blessed the fellow who has not walked
in the counsel of the wicked;
nor loitered along the path of sinners;
nor sat in the seat of the pestilent.
2. But whose delight is in the law
of the Lord;
meditating on the law day and night.
3. Such a person will be like a tree planted by babbling brooks,
a tree which will yield its fruit
in due season,
and its leaves shall not wither and fall.
Whatever that one does shall prosper.
4. Not so the wicked, not so;
rather they are like the chaff
which the wind scatters
from the face of the earth.
5. Therefore the wicked shall not stand up in judgment,
nor sinners in the counsel of the righteous.
6. For the Lord knows the way of the