2-2).
Table 2-1 Properties of cells found in whole blood
Leukocytes and RBCs are similar in density. This makes these two cell types extremely difficult to separate, especially because RBCs outnumber them 1,000 to 1.
Cells in PRF
As shown in Table 2-1, the three main cell types found in PRP and PRF are platelets, leukocytes (WBCs), and RBCs. The entire initial goal of platelet concentrates was of course to concentrate platelets. Because they are the lightest of all cells found in blood, it was possible to utilize a centrifugation device to separate these layers based on their density. Lighter cells (platelets) could therefore be accumulated to the top, followed by leukocytes. Because RBCs are the densest of the group, they tend to migrate downward during the centrifugation process. In an ideal situation, the final PRF matrix should be composed of a high concentration of platelets, leukocytes, and fibrin. It has been shown that the initially developed PRF (also termed L-PRF for leukocyte PRF) concentrates contained greater than 90% platelets and more than 50% leukocytes within a high-density fibrin network when compared to whole blood.5 By utilizing more advanced quantification devices and recently developed methods, our research team has been better able to harvest leukocytes specifically. The lower yield of leukocytes is typically a result of their more similar density to RBCs, making them harder to separate from and accumulate in the upper layers where PRF is collected. This is particularly difficult on fixed-angle centrifuges. Several other methods have been proposed to favor accumulation of cells, including shorter centrifugation times as well as lower centrifugation forces, as discussed later in this chapter (see section on the low-speed centri-fugation concept).6
Leukocytes have been shown to be an integral component of PRF therapy and play a prominent role in wound healing. Studies from basic sciences and animal research have revealed how impactful a role leukocytes play during tissue regeneration by comparing PRP/PRF therapy with and without WBCs.7–9 In these split design studies, the contralateral side receiving leukocytes performed significantly better, promoting researchers and clinicians to develop protocols to better incorporate or harvest leukocytes. Naturally, PRF contains a higher number of leukocytes when compared to the first-generation platelet concentrates PRP and PRGF.
While the role of leukocytes has been well described as host defense against incoming pathogens, they also play a central role in immune modulation of biomaterials and participate in the wound healing process due to their ability to secrete key immune cytokines such as IL-1β, IL-6, IL-4, and TNF-α.2,10,11 They have been highly investigated in PRF therapy, with the impact of centrifugation speed and time affecting both their concentration and location, mainly owing to the fact that they are very similar in density and size to RBCs. Previously, it was demonstrated how faster protocols initially utilized to produce L-PRF were far too high in both g-force and time (2700 rpm for 12 minutes; ~700g).6 This led to the histologic observation that the majority of cells were concentrated either at the buffy coat region or at the bottom of centrifugation tubes within the RBC layer component.6 Based on these observations, it became clear that centrifugation speeds (g-forces) were evidently too high, pushing leukocytes especially down to the bottom of centrifugation tubes and away from the PRF clot. In order to redistribute leukocyte cell numbers across the entire PRF matrix, both a change in centrifugation speed and/or time (lower) as well as a change in the centrifugation device (horizontal centrifugation as opposed to fixed-angle) were deemed necessary to further improve platelet formulations, as reviewed later in this chapter.
Advantages of a 3D Fibrin Network
Fibrin is the activated form of a plasmatic molecule called fibrinogen that converts into fibrin with thrombin. Fibrin formation is one of the first key components to tissue wound healing. When an individual cuts himself, the first event taking place prior to any regeneration is fibrin clot formation. This is why patients on anticoagulant therapy typically do not heal quite as effectively because delayed clotting leads to delayed healing. The obvious advantage of PRF therapy is its ability to accumulate various cell types including platelets without anticoagulants, thereby improving clotting properties. Once a fibrin clot is formed during the centrifugation cycle, cells and GFs are able to be trapped within the 3D fibrin matrix, favoring the slower and gradual release of GFs from PRF over time.12 Fibrin is a soluble fibrillary molecule that is present in high quantity both in plasma itself as well as in the α-granules of platelets. Fibrin therefore plays a determining role in platelet aggregation during hemostasis and is critical to healing. Not surprisingly, the use of fibrin alone (without GFs or living cells as a fibrin glue) has been shown to lead to matrix stabilization favoring tissue stability, cellular invasion, and ultimately tissue regeneration.13–15 However, PRF has numerous advantages in that during the fibrin clot formation, a supraphysiologic concentration of platelets, leukocytes, and GFs are also present, forming a sort of “superclot” consisting of an intimate assembly of cytokines, glycanic chains, and structural glycoproteins enmeshed within a slowly polymerized fibrin network16,17 (Fig 2-2).
Fig 2-2 SEM examination of the fibrin clot revealing a dense and mature fibrin matrix with various cell types entrapped within its matrix.
PRF forms a “superclot” consisting of an intimate assembly of cytokines, glycanic chains, and structural glycoproteins enmeshed within a slowly polymerized fibrin network.
The fibrin scaffold produced following centrifugation has further been identified as a biologic 3D network with the ability for the fibrillar micropores to support cell migration, proliferation, differentiation, and delivery of GFs. Platelets have theoretically been described as being massively trapped within the fibrin network, and the release of GFs is largely dictated by the actual timespan in which the 3D PRF scaffold is broken down (typically within 2–3 weeks).18 One of the major advantages of PRF when compared to PRP is the fact that by simply removing anticoagulants, a fibrin matrix is formed with a natural autologous delivery system capable of slowly and gradually releasing GFs over time.7–9 This leads to GF delivery over a period of 2 to 3 weeks as opposed to only a few hours observed in PRP.12
Finally, stem cells exist naturally in whole blood, albeit at extremely low levels.19,20 Stem cells have the ability and potential to differentiate into many cell types, including adipocytes, osteoblasts, and chondrocytes. Many commercial enterprises report that mesenchymal stem cells (MSCs) exist in extremely high numbers in PRF or that only certain protocols or machinery favor their accumulation, but these reports have not been validated in any high-quality peer-reviewed journal. While future research investigating the impact of MSCs in blood is necessary, it may represent a potential future strategy to isolate MSCs relatively easily at low cost.
The commercial claims that MSCs exist in extremely high numbers in PRF or that only certain protocols or machinery favors their accumulation have not been validated.
Growth Factors in Blood
Naturally, GFs are critical to wound healing, and a variety of GFs have been commercialized as recombinant human sources once their roles were established. GFs are largely responsible for the migration of cells and also play a critical role in their adhesion, proliferation, and differentiation. While GFs exist in all tissues, it is important to note that blood serves as a main reservoir of numerous GFs and cytokines promoting angiogenesis and